iPad vs Other e-Readers, the Verdict

In relating all the details of my Apple vs PC series, I almost forgot to tell you all about the result of my e-reader  search.  I actually bought several, and brought them back, as well as tried a few more that I never bought.

In the end I decided on the iPad.  This device was so superior and had so many more features than anything else, it became a very easy decision.

One of the most important deciding factors was the size.  I like to read a variety of things and when it came to magazines and newspapers, the other e-readers just made the experience too unpleasant.  Maybe this would not be an issue for someone with younger eyes, but for me there was no question.

Another very important factor was the LCD screen.  I do a great deal of my reading at night and I liked the idea of being able to read without adding any extra light to the situation.  This brings up another thing that has turned out to be fantastic for me.

I tend to come up with most of my creative ideas at night; usually while sleeping.  I’ll wake up at 3am with this great idea that needs to be written down or it will be gone from my mind in a matter of seconds.

In the past, I either didn’t bother writing it down, or rudely woke up my wife by turning on a light so I could jot down my idea.  Now I can just reach over to the night stand, tap one button and the iPad is instantly ready for input.  Tap the “Notes” icon and up comes an electronic version of a yellow legal pad.  Tap anywhere on the pad and up comes an extremely easy to use keyboard to quickly enter the idea.

I have the iPad housed in a thin case that opens up like a book.  Since you can rotate the iPad in any direction and the screen will stay upright, I can position the cover of the case so the light does not bother my wife.  Also, the iPad screen can be dimmed down quite low.

I also chose the iPad because of it’s functionality in other areas.  In this high-tech age we live in, you can really get carried away carrying around lots of gadgets.  The iPad combines so many of them that not much else is needed.

It has an amazing calendar, email, notes, calculator, and the Safari web browser.  Then there’s the GPS with extremely fast response time and very detailed, high-resolution maps.  And finally there’s iTunes, a headphone jack, decent sounding speaker, apps for Nook and Kindle books, it’s own iBook reader, and apps for just about anything else you could want.  I have Sudoku, Scrabble, and Chess and they all look and work great.

Combine all that with 10 hours of battery life (for continuous use) and you have a really nice device.  10 hours may not seem like much compared to the days and weeks of e-ink readers, but I find that I only need to charge it about once a week.

Even though I leave it on all the time, when the screen turns off the battery life is greatly extended.  So if you’re using it like a Daytimer and organizer and not using it constantly all day long, I suspect one charge could last 3 or 4 weeks.

There are some additional technical reason I chose the iPad but I’ll get into those in a later post.

So now it’s your turn!  If you’ve got an e-reader already, which one did you get?  If not, which one do YOU think is the best?  Please leave a comment and also click the “Like” button in the Facebook box in the left margin if you enjoyed the article.

Thanks for visiting!


Kindle vs Nook – Do All Books Cost $9.99?

Is there a difference in the cost of books between Kindle and Nook?  Do all books cost around $9.99?  In my search for the perfect e-reader, I decided to answer this question once and for all.  I started by checking a bunch of identical titles on Barnes & Noble.com, Amazon.com, and Apple.com.  I then verified my findings with owners of the various products and some sales people.  What I found was surprising.

First of all, I found that most sales people had no idea what the answer to this question was.  Almost all of them thought there was no difference in price.  What got me thinking about this was a comment that a passing customer made to me in Best Buy while I was doing research for the review.  While looking over e-readers she said that I should buy the Kindle because the Nook book prices were higher.  I really found the comment puzzling because I had thought everybody's prices would be the same.  Especially since no price advantages are ever mentioned in any advertising.  I would think if one was lower than the others this would be mentioned as a selling point.

What I found is there can be big price differences between the three services.  The greatest differences seemed to be with specialty items like technical books.  For example, the most significant price difference I found was on a book called "Professional WordPress – Design and Development." It was nearly $9.00 more on Barnes & Noble than on Amazon.  It was not available in the Apple Store.  Most books varied by a dollar or two with Amazon being almost always the lowest.  For main stream books like popular novels and New York Times Best Sellers, Amazon's price was generally around a dollar less than the other two services.

I was unable to find an instance when Amazon was more than the other two.  However, it would be nearly impossible for one person to check out all the offerings available on all the services.  I did however manage to find a couple of sales people that were aware of pricing differences.  They said that it depends on the type of the book in question.  Each service seems to specialize in certain types of books.  I was told for example, that Amazon would generally have lower prices on technical books. Another very important consideration in my opinion is that all books are not available on all services.  I found some books on Barnes & Noble that served a specialty programming niche but were not available on the other services.  So tying yourself to one service could cause you to miss out on some good offerings.

The moral of the story is to check for yourself.  If you haven't purchased an e-reader yet and your library focuses on a certain type of book, you might want to see who's got the best prices.  If your library is more varied (like mine) you might want an e-reader that is not tied to just one service.  I tested all the leading e-readers and settled on the iPad for just that reason; it can download books from all the services.  This allows me to find the best price regardless of where it's from and have every possible title available.

In summary, all books do not cost $9.99.  The prices vary all over the place, just like in the bookstore.  Also, just like in bookstores, the prices can be very different between competing services.

If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment and consider joining our mailing list by entering your name and email in the box at the right.

Thanks for visiting!